The myth of Flat Earth?





You've probably heard that the Medieval people thought the Earth was flat. Is this true? I'll show you some images from various manuscripts, as well as quotes from two well-known Medieval scholars.


Regarding this issue, here’s what Bede Venerabilis (673-735) says:


“Why the same days are unequal in length?


The reason why the same (calendar) days are of unequal length is the roundness of Earth...” 


Bede, The Reckoning of Time, trans. Faith Wallis (Liverpool University Press, 1999), pp. 91. 


God the Geometer 13th century.


Full quote: 



The Creation of the World and the Expulsion from Paradise

(1445) by Giovanni di Paolo


St. Thomas Aquinas O.P. (1225-1274), the most famous Medieval and Catholic thinker, knew that the Earth was round. Here's what he said:

“[T]he astronomer and the physicist both may prove the same conclusion—that the earth, for instance, is round: the astronomer by means of mathematics (i.e., abstracting from matter), but the physicist by means of matter itself.”

– Summa Theologica, Question 1, First Article. 

Thomas Aquinas O.P.


Medieval depiction of a spherical earth with different seasons at the same time, from the book "Liber Divinorum Operum" (1163-1173) by Hildegard von Bingen



According to Jeffrey Burton Russell, a Medieval history expert, the idea that Medieval people believed in a flat Earth was introduced between the end of the nineteenth and the beginning of the twentieth centuries.


You can read his article here.

Islamic depiction of Earth


Further reading: 

Falk, Seb. The Light Ages: The Surprising Story of Medieval Science .W. W. Norton & Company, 2020.

Hannam, James. God's Philosophers: How the Medieval World Laid the Foundations of Modern Science. Icon Books Ltd, 2009.


Pernoud, Régine. Those Terrible Middle Ages: Debunking the Myths. Ignatius Press, 2000.


Cormack, Lesley B. "Flat Earth or round Sphere: Misconceptions of the Shape of the Earth and the Fifteenth-century Transformation of the World." Ecumene 1, no. 4 (1994): 363-85. Accessed July 9, 2021. http://www.jstor.org/stable/44251730.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How the Enlightenment ideology obscured our historiographical imagination

Image
The Ancient of days by William Blake (1794) I’m a graduate in Medieval Studies, and when I try to explain some myths about it, people look at me as if I was insane. The Enlightenment propaganda is so strong, that telling the truth about Medieval era sounds like a crazy right-wing conspiracy theory. And this is a serious problem. Many school textbooks, media, etc. promote most of these myths, which are inherently biased and dangerous, because they distort the truth.  The Enlightenment historiography is still the most successful propaganda ever made; it refused to die, because the [anti-Christian] sentiment which these thinkers had promoted seems to be popular ever since. Demonizing the Other is the best way to begin a fight, because it gives you the feeling of the moral superiority. In our case, this has been done by distorting and misinterpreting historical facts, and inventing myths and false villains and heroes. This genius propaganda has affected and influenced most of us, therefore
Read more

The issue with neoliberalism: a traditional Conservative critique

Image
  L'Allegoria della Virtù e del Vizio by Lorenzo Lotto Recognizing the disastrous history of totalitarian regimes, R. Reagan and M. Thatcher minimized the government and promoted the free market, thinking they would give more liberty to the individual and prevent the rise of totalitarianism. But evidently, they had 'forgotten' about the existence of mega-corporations—that grew big enough to fill up the governments' place/role, in which they systematically impose certain ideologies, and of course, exploit and oppress the Middle and Working classes. Their idea of individualism, of course, had gone too far, at a point which one may think they had forgotten about the existence of common good and society—whose existence Thatcher and a few neoconservative thinkers and politicians had begun to deny. If one thinks deeply, the concept of the neoliberal Free Market is quite nihilistic and indifferent in its nature. The idea of ethics, common good, and culture doesn't seem t
Read more

History of the miraculous portrait of Our Lady of Scutari

Image
  This medieval painting is called "Mater Boni Consilii" (en. Mother of Good Counsel; sq. Zoja e K'shillit t'mirë), also known as "Our Lady of Scutari" (sq. Zoja e Shkodrës). It's located in the Augustinian Church of Genazzano, near Rome. Many scholars believe it was painted by the Italian renaissance artist Gentile da Fabriano during the first two decades of XV century. What makes it special, is its story. According to the Medieval legend, on the feast day of St. Mark, in 1467, [during the time of the Albanian-Ottoman war], two Albanian noblemen were praying in the church, asking for protection of the Holy Mary before exiling to Italy. The image, which was located in Shkodër (it. Scutari), was, allegedly, lifted in the air by angels, who announced the fall of the city under the Ottomans, and accompanied the two men to Rome. Thus, miraculously, it was transported to Genazzano. The locals, as the tradition says, in the midst of celebration, heard "
Read more